I'm sure you weren't paying that close of attention but in each of the pictures from yesterday's post I'm wearing different shoes. After the half marathon in April my trusty Asics were completely shot and needed replacing. I felt like I was ready for a change......like I had outgrown the traditional running shoes I'd been sporting for the past year-and-a-half. I knew several people that had transitioned into more lightweight shoes and I love a good bandwagon so I decided it was time to hop on as well. Thus began my journey to finding my very own shoe utopia.
Shoe #1: I stupidly went to a large discount shoe store to replace my worn out kicks and decided on the Saucony Mirage 2.
All I could think about as I was looking in the mirror at them on my feet was "They are light. They are flashy. I want them." Initially, I couldn't figure out what size to get and frequently have trouble with numbness in my feet and blistering so I thought it would be wise to experiment with a larger size. Made sense in theory, but failed in execution. I ran in them three times and disliked them so much that if it came down to never running again or wearing these shoes while running, I was never running again. The worst part of the situation was that I spent $100 on shoes that I couldn't return because when you go to a store like that, return policies are basically non-existent once you've worn the shoes out in the real world. Expensive lesson learned. Final assessment: Too Big
Shoe #2: After that debacle, I wised up and decided that I needed to go somewhere and get some help (keep the jokes to yourself, please). First stop: a large sporting goods store. Return policy is a little bit better but the inept high school students they had staffing the shoe department just pissed me off and I ended up leaving empty handed. Ok, fine. I'll go get fitted at a specialty running store. Second stop:
Fleet Feet Murfreesboro. I probably spent an hour there getting measured and trying on/running in various shoes. The last pair I tried was the Brooks PureCadence from their
Pure Project line (please excuse the stock photo - I deleted all the pics of it off my phone much the way I would photos of an ex-boyfriend. What can I say? Break-ups are rough on me).
I really didn't even want to try them on. I'd read that they were a stability shoe and I was certain that was
not what I needed. Based on the Mirage Massacre, I realized that, clearly, I am no expert and listened to the knowledgeable salesman and guess what? I loved them. They were lightweight , encouraged my natural forefoot strike, and had a satisfaction guarantee (YESS!!!). I was sure it was a match made in running shoe heaven. Sadly, it was not meant to be. I went out running that evening and could feel my toes smashing into the outside seam on the right shoe the whole time. I went back in the next day to chat with the owner and she felt like it was probably more a style issue than an incorrect size (which turned out to be true - the half size up didn't feel any better - just bigger) and suggested I try the Pure Flow. I was not happy about this considering the fact that I was already emotionally attached to these beautiful shoes despite the fact that they made my feet ache. The store didn't have the Flow in stock, so while I waited for them to come in, I continued running in the Cadence to see if I could work out the kinks. They went from bad to worse and I ended up with a blister on the top of my big toe. Final Assessment: Too small
Shoe #3: It took about a week and a half for the PureFlow to come in.....but it was well worth the wait! I had originally ordered the red/turquoise ones but Fleet Feet couldn't get those in so they ordered an equally beautiful Neon Purple!
They are literally the color of a purple highlighter! No joke! See??
I could tell immediately when I put them on that the toe box was wider than the Cadence and felt so much roomier in the forefoot. I jogged around outside in them a bit and decided they were the better option. Of course, the very same night, Molly and I took to the Murfreesboro Greenway for a test run. Aside from the usual numbness I feel in my right foot sometimes they felt great and I'm very optimistic that come October, these will be on my feet when I set a new PR running The Murfreesboro Middle Half. Just like the Cadence they are super lightweight - coming in at only 7.5 ounces per shoe - and again, encourage a forefoot strike. They're fairly similar shoes but the combination of the wider toe box on this one and the fact that it is a neutral versus a stability shoe made it the winner in the end. Final Assessment: Just Right!
So there is a recap of my search for the perfect running shoe. I am completely aware of the fact that I complicate what is meant to be simple and that this didn't have to be the epic process that it turned into. Between wanting to prevent injury if at all possible during my training and also being careful not to just throw money away without being completely convinced that what I'm spending it on is a good investment, it takes me a little longer than normal to make a decision and slap down the cash for expensive kicks. My only hope is that I haven't jinxed them by blogging about them already.